Gazeta Buenos Aires - Maui Water Board Chair Urges Mayor to Compel Planning Director’s Participation

NYSE - LSE
RBGPF -1.6% 75 $
GSK -0.13% 47.76 $
BTI -1.11% 56.84 $
RYCEF -4.24% 16.5 $
RELX -0.75% 38.54 $
VOD -1.15% 14.02 $
NGG 0.13% 79.82 $
RIO -2.71% 72.73 $
CMSC -1.35% 18.9 $
BCE 2.42% 21.86 $
BCC -2.17% 63.01 $
BP -1.08% 42.75 $
CMSD -0.54% 18.65 $
JRI -1.71% 10.53 $
AZN -0.61% 174.35 $
Maui Water Board Chair Urges Mayor to Compel Planning Director’s Participation
Maui Water Board Chair Urges Mayor to Compel Planning Director’s Participation

Maui Water Board Chair Urges Mayor to Compel Planning Director’s Participation

The Maui County Board of Water Supply has unanimously approved a letter to Mayor Richard Bissen demanding that Planning Director Jacky Takakura formally appear before the board. Chair Nichole Inouye-Nohara argues that Takakura’s limited participation is impairing the board’s ability to advise on water resource availability for development projects, a duty mandated by the county charter.

Text size:

The Maui County Board of Water Supply has formally requested that Mayor Richard Bissen direct Planning Director Jacky Takakura to appear before the board and provide a written explanation of her department’s responsibilities regarding water resource availability. The move follows months of reported friction between the two agencies over coordination on development proposals.

In a draft letter dated Oct. 17, Board Chair Nichole Inouye-Nohara wrote that Takakura’s "repeated refusal to participate in board proceedings" directly impairs the board’s ability to discharge its responsibilities under the Maui County Charter. The board unanimously voted to approve the letter on Thursday.

"This is more than a matter of attendance," Inouye-Nohara wrote in the draft correspondence to Bissen. "There is a rather remarkable mis-apprehension of the kuleana [responsibility] of the Board of Water Supply within the administration."

The board’s letter asserts that Takakura’s insufficient participation perpetuates ambiguity regarding Planning Department procedures and undermines cooperation among county departments. Inouye-Nohara stated that the board is not seeking to interfere with the Planning Department’s lawful administrative authority but rather seeks the cooperation necessary to perform its own Charter-mandated advisory function.

The conflict traces back to April 3, when Inouye-Nohara first reached out to Takakura shortly after she assumed the helm of the Planning Department following the resignation of former director Kate Blystone. Inouye-Nohara invited Takakura to a May 21 board meeting to discuss how water supply is evaluated for commercial and private development, how the department tracks overall water conditions across Maui, and how these considerations are addressed at various planning stages.

In her response, Takakura noted that some of these topics had previously been addressed by Blystone. "That might have been a year ago," she wrote, sharing excerpts from the Maui County Charter specifying the duties of both departments. Takakura did not attend the May 21 meeting.

The board subsequently invited Takakura to participate in another meeting over the summer. Inouye-Nohara explained that the goal was to improve water resource planning for Maui’s future and streamline coordination between the Planning Department and the Department of Water Supply. She identified "important gaps in the planning process regarding countywide water supply" based on previous discussions with Blystone and water department staff.

At the end of her letter, Inouye-Nohara attached a document outlining specific questions for Takakura, including who in the department can evaluate water use and supply, Takakura’s assessment of Maui’s resource planning process, and how the department tracks cumulative water usage. In her response, Takakura declined to address most of these questions, instead sharing a department organization chart and referring board members back to the charter.

The dispute intensified during an Oct. 15 board meeting. A county spokesperson stated Wednesday that Takakura has made every effort to appear when requested, declining only when she had schedule conflicts. Responding to the board’s letter requesting her presence at the 1:30 p.m. meeting that day, a planning department secretary emailed that the director was already scheduled to attend an in-person meeting at 2 p.m. on the same date.

Despite this scheduling conflict, Takakura did attend the Oct. 15 meeting. The board shuffled its agenda to take up the discussion with her immediately after public testimony concluded at 1:41 p.m. However, board members chose to reschedule the item so they would have more time to speak with Takakura, according to meeting minutes.

The board’s letter emphasizes that the Maui County Charter expressly establishes the planning director as a "non-voting ex-officio member" of the Board of Water Supply. Therefore, Takakura’s participation is described as an integral part of the board’s institutional structure, not merely an optional courtesy. The board relies on access to information about planning decisions and administrative procedures to advise on issues such as water-resource availability, system capacity, and future water demand.

Takakura previously told Civil Beat that she had only agreed to take on the role of planning director for the remainder of Bissen’s current term, which runs through the end of this year.

Shay Chan-Hodges, the former water board chair whose term ended in 2021, said she could not speak to the current situation or administration. However, she emphasized the historical importance of departmental collaboration. "Obviously the use of water is crucial to any kind of development and housing, which has come up over and over again," Chan-Hodges said. "Communication overall, I think generally has not historically been great at the county."

The board’s request for a written explanation from Takakura remains pending as the administration reviews the formal correspondence.

X.Sosa--GBA