Gazeta Buenos Aires - Emergency Doctors Warn Hospitals Cannot Guarantee Patient Safety This Winter

NYSE - LSE
CMSC 0.63% 19.08 $
RYCEF 1.5% 17.36 $
GSK -1.36% 48.58 $
BTI -1.13% 58.5 $
RIO -4.7% 75.9 $
RELX -0.95% 39.02 $
RBGPF -0.46% 75.3 $
NGG -0.41% 82.22 $
AZN -1.96% 178.76 $
VOD -2.49% 14.85 $
BP -3.7% 43.25 $
BCE 0.18% 22.06 $
JRI -1.11% 10.85 $
BCC 0.87% 65.71 $
CMSD 0.75% 18.78 $
Emergency Doctors Warn Hospitals Cannot Guarantee Patient Safety This Winter
Emergency Doctors Warn Hospitals Cannot Guarantee Patient Safety This Winter

Emergency Doctors Warn Hospitals Cannot Guarantee Patient Safety This Winter

The Irish Association for Emergency Medicine (IAEM) has issued a stark warning that many hospitals are nearing breaking point and cannot guarantee patient safety as the winter season begins. The association criticized the normalization of treating patients in corridors, stating it must never be accepted as a cost of balancing budgets, while the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation highlighted critical staffing shortages.

Text size:

The Irish Association for Emergency Medicine (IAEM) has declared that many hospitals are at breaking point and unable to guarantee patient safety as the winter season approaches. In a statement released on Wednesday, the organization condemned the practice of treating patients in corridors, asserting that such conditions must never be accepted as the price of balancing a budget.

The IAEM’s warning comes in response to recent comments by Health Service Executive (HSE) Chief Executive Anne O’Connor regarding financial management within the health system. Speaking on RTÉ Radio One’s ‘This Week’ programme, O’Connor emphasized that expenditure must be used more effectively, specifically calling for greater monitoring of spending on agency staff used to fill service gaps.

In its rebuttal, the IAEM stressed that emergency departments operate continuously regardless of financial constraints. "When a patient arrives in an Emergency Department with an acute illness or injury, in their time of need, we do not tell them that the hospital cannot treat them because of budgetary constraints," the association stated. "Emergency departments never close. Their doors are open 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, and demand does not stop when a budget runs out."

The organization identified a structural lack of capacity as the primary driver of corridor care. The IAEM noted that Ireland lacks sufficient acute hospital beds, as well as egress beds in rehabilitation, step-down, and long-term care facilities. Without these discharge options, admitted patients have nowhere to go, resulting in treatment on trolleys and in hallways.

The association described corridor care not merely as a matter of comfort but as a "safety and major dignity failure in modern healthcare" that should never be normalized. Citing a 2022 study published in the Emergency Medicine Journal, the IAEM highlighted the clinical risks involved: the research found one extra death within 30 days for every 82 admitted patients who wait six to eight hours in an emergency department before moving to a ward.

While acknowledging investment in community care under the Sláintecare reform program, the IAEM argued that this has not reduced emergency department attendances. Instead, visits continue to rise, driven by a growing and aging population with complex needs. The association called for timely access to advanced diagnostics, including CT, MRI, and ultrasound services available around the clock, arguing that faster diagnosis leads to shorter stays and more efficient bed usage.

With winter upon them, the IAEM urged the government and the HSE to deliver a funded, multi-annual plan for acute and egress bed capacity. "Treating patients in this manner must never be accepted as the price of balancing a budget," the statement concluded.

The warning coincides with the government’s finalization of a supplementary budget of €780 million to cover overspends in health services for the current year.

Simultaneously, the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation (INMO) has raised alarms regarding staffing controls. The union reported that 137 directors and assistant directors of nursing and midwifery have expressed serious concerns about the HSE’s recruitment restrictions. INMO General Secretary Phil Ní Sheaghdha described these warnings as coming from clinical experts responsible for patient care.

"Directors and assistant directors of nursing and midwifery have told us that they cannot safely staff services if they are prevented from filling essential nursing and midwifery vacancies," Ní Sheaghdha said. He warned that ignoring these concerns would lead to inevitable consequences for patients and staff, noting that the workforce is already overstretched.

Data from the INMO’s Trolley Watch initiative underscores the scale of the crisis. On Wednesday morning alone, 765 patients were recorded in hospitals without a bed, with 522 of those located in emergency departments.

F.Alonso--GBA