Gazeta Buenos Aires - Land Reform Requires Agricultural Education to Succeed, Experts Warn

NYSE - LSE
VOD -1.15% 14.02 $
BCE 2.42% 21.86 $
GSK -0.13% 47.76 $
RELX -0.75% 38.54 $
AZN -0.61% 174.35 $
NGG 0.13% 79.82 $
CMSC -1.35% 18.9 $
RYCEF -7.13% 16.4 $
RBGPF -0.4% 75 $
RIO -2.71% 72.73 $
BCC -2.17% 63.01 $
BTI -1.11% 56.84 $
BP -1.08% 42.75 $
CMSD -0.54% 18.65 $
JRI -1.71% 10.53 $
Land Reform Requires Agricultural Education to Succeed, Experts Warn
Land Reform Requires Agricultural Education to Succeed, Experts Warn

Land Reform Requires Agricultural Education to Succeed, Experts Warn

South Africa has transferred approximately 19 million hectares of farmland since 1994, yet a significant portion remains underused or unproductive. Authors Murendeni Liphadzi and Wellington Thwala argue that land reform cannot succeed without integrating compulsory agricultural education into the national school curriculum to equip beneficiaries with essential farming and business skills.

Text size:

South Africa has transferred or restored approximately 19 million hectares of farmland since the advent of democracy in 1994, representing roughly a quarter of the country’s freehold farmland, according to data from the Bureau for Food and Agricultural Policy. Despite this massive transfer of assets, the Vumelana Advisory Fund has warned that the restored land remains largely underused or unproductive.

The central challenge is not merely the movement of land titles but the absence of a corresponding pipeline of skilled individuals capable of managing agricultural enterprises. Authors Murendeni Liphadzi and Wellington Thwala argue that while farmers often lack post-settlement support, government departments fail to coordinate effectively, and many struggle to access markets, there is a more fundamental gap: the education system does too little to build the necessary skills base.

Land reform requires individuals who can grow food, manage complex businesses, secure finance, and navigate supply chains. Liphadzi and Thwala contend that this pipeline must begin at the school level. Currently, access to agricultural learning is determined by geography and resource availability rather than national policy. In March 2025, the Department of Basic Education informed parliament that agricultural sciences is not offered as a standalone subject before grade 10. By July 2025, the department clarified that schools and districts decide whether to offer agricultural subjects in grades 10 to 12 based on learner demand and available resources, with no plan to make agriculture compulsory.

This decentralized approach leaves rural learners, who live closest to land-reform projects, among the least likely to have opportunities to study agriculture. Although the department announced a pilot program for agricultural studies in grades 8 and 9 at schools of skills in March 2025, with full implementation planned for 2026, the authors argue that parliamentary oversight is needed to ensure the rollout progresses and that schools receive adequate support.

The urgency of integrating agriculture into education is underscored by economic data. Agriculture is a critical source of employment and export earnings, yet it faces significant headwinds. Statistics South Africa’s Quarterly Labour Force Survey for the third quarter of 2026 recorded a national unemployment rate of 33.7%, an increase from 33.6% in the previous quarter, despite total employment increasing by 101,000 to 16.8 million. In contrast, the agriculture sector recorded a quarterly employment decline of 34,000, highlighting its vulnerability and the need to protect and expand its job-creating potential.

Financially, the sector remains vital. Agricultural exports reached a record $15.1 billion (approximately R261 billion) in 2025, according to Agbiz chief economist Wandile Sihlobo. However, Sihlobo notes that black farmers account for only about a tenth of commercial output, while the government holds approximately 2.5 million hectares of underused agricultural land. The opportunity for economic participation exists, but the question remains how more people can take part in it.

To address this disparity, Liphadzi and Thwala propose a comprehensive policy: compulsory agricultural learning from primary school to grade 12, with lessons tailored to each age group. In early grades, learners would explore food gardens, soil, water, and nutrition through subjects such as life orientation and natural sciences. For grades 7 to 9, all learners should take agricultural studies, extending the department’s existing pilot. In grades 10 to 12, every school should offer a supported agricultural pathway, requiring all learners to complete a practical module in agribusiness and food systems.

The authors emphasize that this should be a coherent learning journey rather than a superficial gardening activity added to the school calendar. The curriculum would progress from basic questions about how food grows and what plants need to more complex topics including climate, animal care, food safety, farm technology, budgeting, and market routes. Older learners would engage in practical projects, identifying local needs, planning products or services, estimating costs, considering risks, and explaining distribution strategies.

This approach aims to connect classroom knowledge with real-world choices and local opportunities. While school gardens can serve as useful learning spaces, they are not a substitute for teaching agricultural science, business skills, and the wider food system. The authors also stress that learners should not be expected to provide unpaid labor for school or commercial production; practical learning must build knowledge and confidence while respecting learners’ time and rights.

Critics may ask why agriculture should be compulsory if not every child will become a farmer. The authors argue that the aim is broader than training future farmers. Learners need to understand where food comes from, how land can support livelihoods, and how agricultural businesses operate. Agriculture opens doors to careers in food science, logistics, technology, finance, and law. Since all citizens make decisions about food, water, and land, a basic understanding of these systems is useful regardless of career choice.

Acknowledging real constraints such as shortages of teachers, land, and equipment, the authors call for a phased rollout starting with schools that are ready. Teacher training and practical support should be developed through agricultural colleges and technical and vocational education and training (TVET) colleges. Universities, research institutions, local farmers, and businesses can contribute expertise through carefully structured partnerships, while schools retain responsibility for learners’ education. Schools without access to land can still teach agricultural knowledge through partnerships, visits, demonstrations, simulations, and other practical learning methods.

A well-designed program should not assume every school can establish a farm or garden. Instead, it should set a minimum level of learning all schools can provide, then make additional facilities and specialist pathways available as capacity grows. To address the crowded curriculum, agriculture can first be built into subjects where it already appears, rather than simply adding more hours to the school day. However, integration must be planned; if agriculture is everyone’s responsibility in theory, it can disappear in practice. The department must set clear learning outcomes, provide teaching materials, and ensure teachers have time and training.

The proposal also addresses historical context. For many families, farm work evokes memories of the 1913 Natives Land Act and generations of poorly paid labor. Agricultural education must prepare learners to be owners, entrepreneurs, and innovators, not confine them to drudgery. It must include land rights, business ownership, technology, and the history of dispossession. In 2020, then Eastern Cape education MEC Fundile Gade called for agriculture to be compulsory in the province’s schools, stating, “We must move into a space where we are the owners of our own industries.”

The authors call on the minister of basic education to present a costed, phased plan for compulsory agricultural learning, beginning with schools and provinces that are ready. Provincial departments should outline their pilot programs and support mechanisms, while parliament should track the rollout and assess whether learners are gaining meaningful knowledge and practical experience.

Land reform cannot end with land changing hands; it must connect ownership to education, research, technology, and the skills to build sustainable businesses. The goal is not to make every learner a farmer but to ensure every learner can see the opportunities in agriculture and has a chance to develop the skills to pursue them. A country that wants its land back must also build the knowledge to work it. Without agricultural education, land reform remains unfinished.

South Africa must pair ownership with agricultural education from primary school, tied to its basic education, higher education, research, and industrialization strategies. This integration will allow generations to gain the skills, technology, and entrepreneurial ability to make the land productive. The aim is to build agricultural literacy, practical competence, and an appreciation of food production, ensuring that land reform delivers tangible economic benefits to those who inherit it.

E.Navarro--GBA